Review of ‘The Gospel in the Marketplace of Ideas’ by Paul Copan and Kenneth D. Litwak

The-Gospe-in-the-Marketplace Paul Copan and Kenneth D. Litwak, The Gospel in the Marketplace of Ideas: Paul’s Mars Hill Experience for Our Pluralistic World (Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2014). Paperback / Kindle 

Among American evangelicals, it is a truism to say that America is fast becoming a post-Christian nation. The nation’s increasing diversity combined with the rapid rise of religious “nones” have resulted in a very different religious landscape than the one depicted in Will Herberg’s mid-20th-century classic, Protestant—Catholic—Jew, where those three religious constituted Americans’ religious choices. This new landscape requires evangelical Christians to adopt new methods in their evangelistic mission to the current generation.

Why? Because many of our methods assume that the people we are talking to agree with us on basic assumptions about the authority of the Bible, the nature of God, the necessity of atonement, and the reasonableness of faith. For much of American history, evangelism thus consisted of calling nominal Christians to practice a more authentic faith. In our increasingly non-Christian and post-Christian nation, however, it is unsafe to make any of those assumptions.

In their new book, The Gospel in the Marketplace of Ideas, Paul Copan and Kenneth D. Litwak examine Paul’s Mars Hill sermon (Acts 17:16–34) to see what insights the Bible itself supplies to evangelical Christians who wish to proclaim the eternal gospel in temporally relevant manner. Among Paul’s evangelistic sermon in Acts, the Mars Hill sermon best approximates our own cultural situation. Athens was a pre-Christian, pluralistic culture, whose religious and philosophical assumptions and practices differed dramatically from Paul’s. And yet, Paul found a way to speak meaningfully to the Athenians, affirming what he could in their culture, while providing a critique of those beliefs and practices that kept them from seeing their need for faith in Jesus Christ.

This dual-movement of Jesus-centered affirmation and critique will have a different flavor in 21st-century America, of course. But the logic of the approach will be the same.

  • Distinguish between persons and beliefs.
  • Describe the unknown God.
  • Point to signals of transcendence.
  • See evangelism and apologetics as interrelated process.
  • Challenge contemporary idolatries/ideologies.
  • Above all, point to Jesus as the climax of history and the fulfillment of our highest ideals.

As we follow Paul’s Mars Hill evangelistic methodology, we will find that some of our listeners will sneer, just as some Athenians sneered at Paul. But some will believe. It is for them that we must “become all things to all people so that by all possible means [we] might save some” (1 Corinthians 9:22).

P.S. If you found this review helpful, please vote yes on my review page.

One thought on “Review of ‘The Gospel in the Marketplace of Ideas’ by Paul Copan and Kenneth D. Litwak

  1. RE; ‘The Gospel in the Marketplace of Ideas.’ Authors Copan and Liwak use Paul’s Mars Hill discourse to make several interesting observations and suggestions meant to enhance evangelism in our time. Permit me to offer some observations about Paul’s method of approach to the Grecian pagans that are often overlooked.

    1. His message was the “good news” about Jesus and the resurrection (vs. 18).
    2. This is the message that opened the door to the larger Mars Hill audience.
    3. They not only wanted to hear his message but they also wanted to know what it meant (vs. 20).
    4. He began by not condemning them, but commending them for their spiritual interests (vs. 22).
    5. He cleverly utilized their “Unknown” god to give them an object lesson about the true God (vs. 23).
    6. He claimed to personally know all about their “Unknown God.” (vs. 23).
    7. In one sentence, he gently neuters their many gods and temples of devotion (vss. 24-25).
    8. He negates their philosophy of fate and introduces the sovereign/determinate God (vss. 26-27).
    9. He was inclusive: “…IN HIM WE LIVE…” and “WE ARE HIS OFFSPRING” (Gk: “children” vs. 28).
    10. He cites the resurrection; proof that Christ is now ruling; calling for reconciliation (vss. 30-31).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s